Showing posts with label low carb plans. Show all posts
Showing posts with label low carb plans. Show all posts

Sunday, July 8, 2012

Views on the Schwarzbein Principle

Noelie asked in the previous post if I would jump in. I figured I would. I do love The Schwarzbein Principle, it is rather easy for me most of the time. The nice thing is since doing the low carb stuff years ago, lower carb plans don't bother me either. I try to make my worst days Schwarzbein days, with how much I work out right now, averaging 2 1/2 to 3 hours a day, mostly walking, that can be 30 grams per meal. Honestly I don't even eat that much most of the time. Although I will say lately I'm off because of stress. I still haven't figured out how to deal with it like I should. I haven't been back on it long enough to make it work the way I should. I'm not sure I can manage it for another couple of months other than do my best, and each day be a new day.

The point I wanted to make was what I learned while pregnant, when I worked with a dietician that would throw a fit if I ate less that what she thought I should as far as grams of carbs went. Never mind that my BS were stable, not as low as Berstein would like but good enough, She didn't like it. I learned to fudge the numbers. That is I ate as high fiber stuff as I could, that it would be in the Schwarzbein range of 90 gms in a day, still less than the dietician wanted, much less, but I refused to go there, but the net grams was much less than that. It was closer to Atkins levels. I found that as much as Dr. Schwarbein hated diets like Atkins, thinking they were out of balance, the truth was since she didn't do net carbs, if you ate high fiber, you were doing the other plans. It was an ah, ha moment for me. So that is what I need to get back to doing. I'm trying to eat less protein but I still think my body craves it, so I don't avoid it either.
So even though I know I need to eat less, and probably stick to the 15 grams per meal, and I need to get better at snacks, and even better at eating 3 times a day. I know it can work for me if I'm patient. The problem is I'm not patient. It took a long time for me to loose 50 lbs before, a very long time, try 2 to 3 years. I'm hoping for better this time, but I am doing heavier weights right off, and walking lots more. So my advice is, if you are looking low carb, look at different plans, although they may have different focus in how to do it, they are pretty much the same particularly if you focus on good fats, good protein which includes animal fats, and lots and lots of vegetables, it is manageable. We don't need fruit but if you need to eat them with whole milk yogurt and nuts. That was my treat when pregnant. It can be done.
I had deleted this blog in favor of our wonderful (wonderful because of loving family support) blog about losing weight. It is truly everything I hoped for, but I think the message of what I believe is best for most of us to one DEGREE or another is about carbohydrate restriction.

I am extremely carbohydrate intolerant. I have family genetics against me and I did a turn believing in the rage of diets in the 1980's (Thanks Susan Powter ) that fat was making me fat and the bad dumb luck of losing a lot of weight on that diet the time I did it. I lasted a year. Just a year and my body and mind and soul were falling apart at the end of it. I also knew I could never, ever do it again once I was off of it. Before you say I wasn't make sure I was mixing my carbs to make a whole protein.. ah.. no. I was doing it fine. You know, wheat and beans and the whole nine yards.

Talking about the damage the sugar and yes folks carbs are sugar did to me is hard. It is personal. But I have things that will never fix because of it. If only-if only- if only, I could go back and be a smarter child and say no to the sugar sweets I loved, and no to the carbohydrate items like potatoes and corn I didn't care about. I can't. I can't make my children's lives better by giving them veggies with nice fatty home-made ranch dressing rather than chips or make sure they had cheese chunks, peanut butter on celery and other such treats to make sure they could snack often- my Jay might not be having the health problems he is currently struggling with if I could. I can't.

Then I looked at the REAL science behind carbohydrate restriction. You see people like Powter will quote the 9 calories per gram of fat until you are about choking on your dry cardboard toast. It would be okay if our bodies were machines like a car, but they are not. We need that fat. Our bodies use it for fuel and making important and critical hormones. Our brains actually run more efficiently on ketones than sugar. Insulin, which is raised higher and higher by all that carbohydrate makes sure that many of us are storing all of that carbohydrate as fat. The carbs for us is much higher fat than .. well fat.

Now here is what is important: I do NOT believe that going as low in carbohydrate as I need to go is appropriate for all. We are all different. And example: My son Sean and his gorgeous wife Brynn are slim and healthy. While I would certainly at times LOVE to be the nosey mom (only because I am nosey and not because they are doing anything wrong - in fact Brynn makes a great dill pickle dip I love with veggies great low carb treat for me and one they eat with chips!) and suggest a few things to them, but it would NEVER EVER be to cut carbs out of their life as low as I have to. And frankly as cute as they are it would be silly as I am the fat mom, and they are the healthy and active pair. If they wonder and ask I will suggest a few things, but until then I will respect them for the smart, wonderful adults they are.

Tigersue does the Schwarzbein Principle as much as she can. It's a great way to live in the world and try to plan eating around te different needs of her family.

My husband Randy has issues that I truly believe would improve dramatically if we could figure out how to help him go low carb. The hard part is that while he is not hard to feed- he just has very set ideas about what he wants to eat and different green veggies are just not on that list. I am still trying to work ideas, but it might come with time. I think some ideas will happen as I get healthier.

I started this last round of low carb in January- I wasn't too strict until March. This had in part due to a new position at work. When I wasn't on the phones all the time, I could start what seems to be necessary for me- exercise- and a little more emotional energy to try to deal with figuring out what would help me. I have had time to adjust what I am doing to actually lose weight, and I realized today that I have so much energy! I do stuff in the home that used to "hurt" without even giving it a thought. You know. like cleaning out a cupboard, or just putting away the dishes, or going up and down stairs. Exercise does help, but I also believe that ninety percent is the food.

I hope to presents ideas, studies, and other ideas here. I think..I hope Tigersue hops in as well.